logo
Supply Chain Loss Analysis

Your supply chain is losing money, these are the four opportunities to improve.

Every underfilled truck, every reactive shipment spike, every OTIF miss, every disconnected system — they add up. Most companies are only solving one or two.
98%
Payload utilization — the standard
30 day
Planning horizon — best in class
8
OTIF levers — most pull 2 or 3
72%
Of OTIF failures start in planning
The Problem

Most supply chains are loosing money from four places simultaneously.

The losses are real, recurring, and compounding — but they hide in plain sight because each one looks like a separate operational problem. They are not separate. They are the same planning failure expressed in four different places.

Underfilled trucks force extra carrier runs. Extra runs create shipment bunching. Bunching breaks carrier commitments. Broken commitments drive OTIF failures. OTIF failures cost chargebacks. And every one of those failures is invisible to a system that plans sequentially against yesterday's data.

The standard doesn't fix one. It closes all four — simultaneously, in order, so the gains compound instead of cancel each other out.

Load Optimization
Trucks leaving under capacity
No item master, no constraint-based load building, no dock diagrams. Every load is a one-off. 13 points of recoverable payload left behind on average.
Network Planning
Reactive planning driving spot spend
A 2–3 day planning window means surges arrive as emergencies. Spot market dependency, carrier failures, and cost spikes are the direct result.
OTIF Performance
Chargebacks treated as cost of doing business
72% of OTIF failures originate 2–3 planning cycles upstream. Most teams fix symptoms — expediting, buffers, faster trucks — without ever reaching the root cause.
System Synchronization
Four systems planning against yesterday's data
APS, ERP, WMS, and TMS each planning in isolation. Improvements in one area erode because the other three haven't caught up. The gains never compound.
The Pattern Behind the Problem

Four problems. One compounding effect.

Fix one in isolation and the others pull the gains back. Fix them in order and they multiply.
Load Optimization
Fix load fill first — network, warehouse, and carrier scores follow.
5–10%
Payload gain from math-based loading
40%
Loader productivity improvement

Each underfilled trailer forces a carrier back for another run, increasing spot dependency, compressing dock availability, and creating the shipment bunching that drives OTIF failures. Load optimization is the highest-leverage first move.

Network Planning
A 30-day planning window is worth more than rate renegotiation on most lanes.
3–4%
Freight cost reduction from smoothing alone
60%
Variability reduction achievable

Carriers allocate their best capacity and rates to shippers they can plan around. Consistent, predictable volume commitments stabilize carrier relationships faster than any procurement exercise.

OTIF Performance
72% of OTIF failures start in planning — not on the dock.
72%
Of failures originate upstream in planning
2–3
Planning cycles before the visible miss

Most teams treat OTIF as an execution problem and fix symptoms — faster trucks, more expediting, bigger buffers. The 8 levers work because they fix the upstream planning decisions that create the failures in the first place.

System Synchronization
System sync is what makes every other improvement stick.
98%
First tender acceptance — orchestrated
4
Silos that must plan as one network

You can improve load fill, smooth your network, and pull the OTIF levers — but if your systems still plan sequentially, the gains erode every time reality diverges from the plan. Orchestration is the infrastructure that makes optimization permanent.

The Standard Playbook

What best-in-class operations actually do.

The standard isn't a single fix — it's four interlocking improvements applied in sequence. Each one raises the floor for the next. That's why companies that fix all four see gains that compound, while those that fix one or two see improvements that plateau or erode.

The lowest-scoring area in your operation is always the highest-leverage starting point. Fix it first, and the downstream gains follow without additional effort.

The compounding principle
Load optimization reduces trucks needed. Fewer trucks make network smoothing easier. A smooth network creates the carrier predictability that prevents OTIF failures. And synchronized systems make all three permanent — instead of eroding the next time reality diverges from the plan.
Step 01 — Load Optimization
Item master accuracy → math-based loading → dock diagrams
Audit dimensions and weights for your top 80% of volume SKUs first. Apply constraint-based optimization across weight, cube, stability, and legal limits. Put a visual loading diagram in every loader's hands. This alone closes 30–40% of the fill gap.
Step 02 — Network Planning
Extend the horizon → smooth volume → commit to carriers
Move from a 3-day to a 30-day planning window. Distribute volume evenly across days and lanes — even 50% peak reduction moves most lanes back within core carrier capacity. Predictable volume earns better rates than any rate renegotiation.
Step 03 — OTIF Performance
Pull all 8 levers → trace failures upstream → own it cross-functionally
Book capacity before content. Prioritize by customer criticality. Build a formal exception process. Review OTIF jointly across supply chain, commercial, and operations weekly. Trace every miss 2–3 planning cycles upstream and fix the root cause — not the symptom.
Step 04 — System Synchronization
Turn visibility into decisions → orchestrate across all four systems
Identify exactly where plans break against execution reality — dock capacity, carrier acceptance, labor availability. Build a planning environment where visibility triggers action. APS, ERP, WMS, and TMS operating as one coordinated network is what makes the other three steps permanent.
APS ERP WMS TMS
See It In Your Operation
Your operation is next.
If you ship 5,000+ truckloads a year, ProvisionAi will find the freight costs you're leaving on the table — and show you exactly how to recover them.
See How It Works → Talk to an Expert

Eliminate Hidden Losses
in Your Supply Chain

For companies shipping 5,000+ truckloads/year. Our team will reach out within one business day.

This field is required
This field is required
Please enter a valid work email
This field is required
This field is required
Please select a range
This field is required
✓
You're on our radar.

We'll be in touch within one business day.
In the meantime, explore how ProvisionAi works.